Zhejiang High Court: Related Companies and Individuals Held Jointly Liable for MIFFY Trademark Infringement (Judgment of August 31, 2026)

Mengchun’s Comments

In a recent trademark infringement and unfair competition case involving the well-known MIFFY brand, the Zhejiang High People’s Court upheld a judgment holding seven defendants, including two individuals and five companies, jointly and severally liable for RMB 10 million in damages and reasonable expenses.

The significance of this case lies in the court’s approach to joint infringement by multiple related parties. Although there was no evidence that every defendant had directly participated in every infringing act, the court found that the defendants had acted with a common intention and coordinated their activities across manufacturing, distribution, online sales and the use of infringing marks.

The decision illustrates that joint infringement may be established where the defendants share a common intention to infringe and act in coordination, even if not every defendant directly participates in each specific infringing act. For brand owners, thorough pre-litigation investigations can help identify additional infringers and establish how their activities are connected. This may not only support a finding of joint infringement and joint and several liability, but also improve the prospects of recovering damages through enforcement against multiple liable defendants.

I. Key Issue

Can multiple related companies and individuals be held jointly and severally liable for trademark infringement and unfair competition when not every defendant is shown to have directly committed each infringing act?

The central issue was whether the defendants’ corporate relationships, division of business responsibilities and coordinated conduct were sufficient to establish a common intention to infringe and joint participation in the resulting harm.

II. Court’s Interpretation

Article 1168 of the PRC Civil Code provides that where two or more persons jointly commit a tort causing harm to another person, they shall bear joint and several liability.

The court explained that joint infringement should be assessed by considering both subjective and objective elements:

  1. Common intention: Whether the defendants shared an intention or understanding concerning the infringing conduct and the resulting harm.
  2. Joint conduct: Whether the defendants participated in coordinated activities constituting infringement.
  3. Common harm: Whether their activities contributed to a common harmful result.
  4. Causation: Whether a causal relationship existed between the joint conduct and the resulting harm.

Importantly, the court did not require proof that every defendant had personally carried out each individual act of trademark infringement or unfair competition.

Instead, the key question was whether the defendants’ relationships and conduct, viewed together, demonstrated a common intention and coordinated participation in the infringement.

III. Case Background

The plaintiff, a Dutch company, owned several registered trademarks associated with the well-known MIFFY brand, including marks covering products such as sanitary napkins and baby diapers.

The defendants included a married couple and several related companies involved in manufacturing, distributing and selling diapers, sanitary products and other goods.

The disputed products and online stores used signs including “米菲兔”, “mifet”, “mifetu-go” and rabbit designs. Certain defendants also promoted the products as being authorized by a Dutch MIFFY group, while one company incorporated “米菲” into its registered business name.

The plaintiff brought proceedings before the Hangzhou Intermediate People’s Court, alleging trademark infringement and unfair competition and seeking, among other remedies, RMB 10 million in compensation.

The first-instance court found infringement and unfair competition and held seven defendants jointly and severally liable. Several defendants appealed to the Zhejiang High People’s Court.

IV. Court’s Holding

1. Corporate relationships and common control

The appellate court first examined the relationships among the defendants.

The two individual defendants were married. They held ownership or management positions in several of the defendant companies. One individual had withdrawn as a shareholder of the manufacturing company in 2017 but continued serving as its chairman.

Another defendant company was registered at the manufacturing company’s premises.

These relationships provided important context for examining whether the defendants acted independently or participated in a coordinated infringement operation.

2. Coordinated manufacturing, distribution and sales

The court further examined the respective roles of the defendant companies.

One company manufactured the infringing products, while others acted as distributors, sales entities or operators of online stores.

The evidence showed substantial consistency in the product information, infringing signs, shipping arrangements and dispatch locations associated with online stores operated by different defendants.

Shipping labels from several stores also contained information corresponding to another defendant company and its legal representative.

The court considered these circumstances evidence of coordinated commercial activities rather than isolated transactions among independent businesses.

3. Coordinated use and registration of infringing signs

The defendants had also repeatedly applied to register trademarks, designs and copyrights associated with signs resembling the plaintiff’s MIFFY marks.

Certain defendants authorized others within the group to use the disputed signs.

The court considered these activities, together with the coordinated production and sale of the products, as evidence of a shared intention to imitate the plaintiff’s marks and benefit from their reputation.

4. Joint and several liability

Considering the evidence as a whole, the Zhejiang High People’s Court concluded that the seven defendants had a common intention and had cooperated in carrying out trademark infringement and unfair competition.

Although their individual roles differed, their activities collectively contributed to the same infringement operation.

The court therefore upheld the first-instance finding that they constituted joint infringers and should bear joint and several liability.

The decisive factor was not whether each defendant performed every infringing act, but whether the evidence established a common intention and coordinated participation in the overall infringement.

5. Punitive damages and platform liability

The courts also found that the infringement was intentional and serious.

Relevant circumstances included the reputation of the plaintiff’s trademarks, repeated applications for similar marks, continued infringement despite an earlier effective judgment, and the duration, scale and geographical reach of the infringing sales.

The first-instance court used verifiable sales of approximately RMB 23.28 million from certain online stores and a reference profit margin of 19.6% in assessing the defendants’ gains. Taking into account punitive damages and statutory damages, it awarded RMB 10 million.

The appellate court upheld the award.

By contrast, the online marketplace operator was not found jointly liable. The first-instance court concluded that the platform had fulfilled its reasonable obligations to review the identities of store operators, and the plaintiff had not established that it had participated in or unlawfully assisted the infringement.

This distinction confirms that the finding of joint infringement was based on the particular evidence of common intention and coordinated conduct, rather than mere involvement in the commercial chain.

V. Judgment

The Zhejiang High People’s Court dismissed the appeal and upheld the first-instance judgment.

The seven defendants were ordered to cease the trademark infringement and unfair competition and to pay RMB 10 million in joint and several liability, covering economic losses and reasonable expenses.

One defendant company was additionally required to cease using “米菲” in its business name, while certain defendants were ordered to publish a statement to eliminate the effects of the infringement.

Court: Zhejiang High People’s Court

Date: August 31, 2026

Case No.: (2026) Zhe Min Zhong 149

First-instance Court: Hangzhou Intermediate People’s Court

First-instance Case No.: (2024) Zhe 01 Min Chu 2450

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top